Can a leaking commercial hot water tank be weld repaired?

Usually, yes. Large commercial and condominium hot water storage tanks are steel pressure vessels with a manway, and they're built to be repaired. A leak at a fitting, coupling or flange can be weld repaired in most cases, and the tank goes back into service with limited downtime. A leak through the tank wall can often be repaired too, as long as the steel around it is sound.

Most advice online says a leaking tank has to be replaced. That's true for household water heaters, which are built to be thrown out. It isn't true for large storage tanks.

Where large tanks usually leak

  • Fittings and couplings. Once the anodes are used up, corrosion starts here. This is the most common leak Hydrastone sees.

  • Flanges and the manway, often around worn gaskets.

  • The tank wall, usually where the lining has failed and corrosion has been working on the steel for a while.

Large tanks are wrapped in thick insulation, so the water often shows up at the bottom of the tank, far from the actual leak. Finding the real source comes first.

When a weld repair makes sense

A weld repair is the right fix when the damage is localized and the steel around it still has its strength. Before any welding, the tank should be drained and inspected inside and out, so the repair is based on the actual condition of the steel and not a guess from the outside.

Large tanks can be regulated pressure vessels, and repairs to them have to be done properly. Ask whoever does the work how they handle any inspection the repair requires before the tank goes back into service.

Weld repair and relining together

A weld repair fixes the leak. Relining fixes the reason it happened. When the lining has broken down, Hydrastone repairs the steel and then relines the tank, which restores the barrier between the water and the steel. Together, they can save nearly any large tank whose steel is in decent condition overall.

The cost difference is large. A Hydrastone reline typically costs under $10,000 CAD per tank, depending on the size and condition of the tank. Replacing a large tank is often a six-figure job, because the old tank has to be cut out and the new one rigged into a mechanical room that was built around it.

When weld repair isn't enough

If corrosion has spread through the tank body, or the shell has leaked through in several places, patching one spot won't make the tank reliable. That's when replacement is the right call.

What to do now

Contain the water, isolate the tank if it's safe to do so, and get an internal inspection. Hydrastone inspects, weld repairs and relines large domestic hot water tanks across Canada. Call 416-902-8265 in Toronto, 778-996-8265 in Vancouver or 403-466-8645 in Calgary, or email info@hydrastone.com.

Related reading

Previous
Previous

What is cement relining, and how long does it last?

Next
Next

Planning for large domestic hot water tanks: a guide for building engineers